Replacing Girls After Summit Bid Earned??

[THEJOEL]

If you were good enough to earn the bid you should be good enough to compete with the bid you earned.
Replacing for injury, discipline issues or just an athlete not able/afford to go is completely acceptable.

 

[MomMomMamaMom]

Neither of my children would be happy being replaced, or going with a team that replaced their team members for reasons beyond injury, discipline or financial. So I wouldn't be happy with it. But I will say that there are plenty of other kids/parents on our team(s) that wouldn't bat an eye at seeing others replaced ( probably would have an issue if it was them, but oh well). So I'm not sure a program can even decisively be responsive to its "clientele".

Again, it all boils down to what we view as competitive, and what we deem to be acceptable in terms of competitiveness. And since there isn't really a good way to collectively incorporate everyone's view on the matter, I do believe it is up to our governing body to set the terms for this. Just not sure how they do so while relying on massive financial entanglements.

 

[crazzyeyesassypants]

We haven't gone to Summit and all the shenanigans I'm hearing makes me not want go [emoji45] I really hope they make some new rules this upcoming season.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[oncecoolcoachnowmom]

I may sound like a cranky old lady for this but I'm okay with it.

We did not have Worlds or Summit when actively cheered.

NCA was it and there were no bids to be earned for that.

I almost feel badly for kids now because their ENTIRE season is structured around these two events.

(Yes, I'm aware that shady things surround NCA but you also do not have to fly around the country to be invited to compete there.)

 

[Lindsey Farris]

As a gym owner and coach I would never replace a child from the original bid winning team unless there was an inconsistency in practice attendance or a behavior problem. Even then there would be a progressive discipline policy. I may add athletes for strength, but I wouldn't think of replacing. I'm so sorry this is happening to your child's team. Every gym has a different philosophy and I hope you find a program that is a fit for your family.

 

[Cheermom1969]

As a gym owner and coach I would never replace a child from the original bid winning team unless there was an inconsistency in practice attendance or a behavior problem. Even then there would be a progressive discipline policy. I may add athletes for strength, but I wouldn't think of replacing. I'm so sorry this is happening to your child's team. Every gym has a different philosophy and I hope you find a program that is a fit for your family.

Sidenote: Welcome to Fierceboard. It's always nice to add someone from the west coast on here. The east coasters outnumber us! And I love your gym, nice athletes and nice parents.